Bullying Comeuppance: The Ultimate Punishment

[dunbarbarian]

For more than half of this school year my son Liam has been tormented by a girl in his class named Emily. He has reported this to both of his teachers, school authorities on the playground, and we both have spoken to the principal of the school who assured me something would be done. I asked if he could move classes and I was told there needed to be evidence first

One day at recess Liam was ganged up on and shoved to the ground where Emily stepped on his head, but he said the school "security officer" told him to man up. My son is 11 years old! I'm told this bully openly mocks him in front of the class with cruel insults and hits him with childish sneak attacks in the hallway. She has even poured drinks on him, which the school employees no doubt saw! Despite this I was informed Emily needs to be innocent until proven guilty. A month ago I brought the issue up directly with her parents, who told me something similar as they couldn't imagine their daughter could be so cruel, but their response was more promising because I was allowed to confront Emily and warn her that if what my son was telling me was true this was her one warning to stop it completely, and both her mom and dad told her directly that if the allegations were true she would be punished very, very severely. Emily was asked directly if what Liam was accusing her of was true and she lied, claiming innocence.

At the end of last week, she was caught in the lie. A teacher found her and 2 other girls trying to SHOVE MY SON'S FACE INTO A TOILET. Thankfully my kid was rescued before his dehumanization was complete, and he told me this hadn't happened before but I'm not sure I believe him! It doesn't matter, because she was given an office department referral and her parents were notified. They contacted me that evening, mortified at Emily's behavior and assured me they would do everything they could to make it right and would be in touch. On Saturday I was called and asked if me and Liam were free to come to their house the next day at noon. I asked what this was about, and it ended up being a very intriguing offer.

While Emily's long term punishment was to be grounded for the remainder of the school year and through the summer, she was going to be punished with a belt spanking in the living room as a deterrent to her siblings and also it was bluntly stated that privacy was a privilege she did not deserve, and they wanted to invite Liam and myself as witnesses. I was then informed that, after some deliberation and despite the public nature of the punishment, her parents had decided that the seriousness of Emily's actions warranted a bare bottom spanking and I was asked if that was something I'd be ok with my son witnessing, stating in no uncertain terms that if I approved he would be able to see her genitals as part of the punishment, causing maximum embarrassment to the girl.

In 99.9% of circumstances I would have had a problem with this, but in this case I had no problem at all... but the one whose answer really mattered was Liam's, so that night I asked him. As I put him to bed I told him first that Emily would be grounded for 7 months, but the next day she was going to get a bare bottom spanking with a belt in front of everyone in the house. Liam made eye contact with me, clearly happy with this, and then I told him something he was not expecting whatsoever: if he wanted to, he would be allowed to watch as well. My boy's eyes were wide as saucers. I asked what he thought, and he said he wanted to sleep on it. So I kissed him good night.

The next morning, when I asked him again, he told me he was inclined to show mercy, but then he remembered she stepped on his head and tried to shove his face into a toilet bowl. It was official, and we went over to watch the humiliation of my son's bully at noon.

Emily's father, Alan, answered the door and welcomed us into the house. We met her mother, Rebecca, in the kitchen with a smirking 8-year-old boy named Ethan, Emily's younger brother, and a rather morose looking 16-year-old girl named Jackie. Ethan was instructed to go find his brother, 13-year-old Alan Jr. You could tell the kids knew what was going on, and Alan Sr asked if Liam knew fully what was going to happen, which Liam confirmed. You could tell the kids knew something big was in store as well, and after Ethan returned with Alan Jr, Rebecca declared that the time had come. She went to go get Emily, who was confined to her room. I noticed Alan Jr gave Liam a pat on the shoulder as if to say sorry for his sister, but Emily was about to be very sorry herself.

I asked Alan if his daughter knew what was about to happen, and he said no, because Liam deserved to see the look on her face when she found out what her punishment was going to be. He had given her a warmup spanking not an hour before in the privacy of her bedroom but she was assured that was just the beginning, although she did not know Liam and I were going to be present or just how shameful it was going to be in general.

He told everyone to go in the living room, where we sat in silence until Rebecca returned with Emily, apart from Ethan asking Liam if he was excited. He was scolded by Alan and threatened to be removed if he didn't stay quiet, to which the youngster apologized. Alan tousled Ethan's hair, and told his youngest that the only one who should be speaking is Liam and myself. While I found the trademark annoying little brother (who no doubt would never let Emily forget what was about to happen) cute, I appreciated that gesture. When Emily was escorted into the living room by Rebecca she made direct eye contact with Liam and her face went white with fear. She was instructed to sit down in a chair Alan had placed in the center of the room. The look on Emily's face was just priceless.

She was barefoot, wearing a yellow T-shirt and jean shorts. Rebecca commenced the scolding, admonishing her for tormenting and bullying my son for months and lying about it. She continued by saying Emily lived a very privileged existence and had absolutely no right to be treating anyone that way, and she had been taught so much better. Emily was then asked if she thought being grounded was going to be the only consequence of her actions. There was no response, and she was told if that is what she thought then was sorely mistaken, because it had been decided that her actions called for a more swift, indeed severe punishment. She was getting a spanking, right there in front of the family and in front of her victim.

Emily looked at her father in horror, but Alan's eyes shot darts right back at her. He was clearly on board with the whole thing, but didn't say a word. Emily looked toward the floor, clearly hoping she would wake up from this nightmare. Rebecca turned toward my son and I and informed us that spankings are pretty rare in the household, and when they do occur they are mostly behind closed doors, but exceptions have been made in the past for deterrence of the other kids from the same misbehavior as well as to make the embarrassment felt by the one who misbehaved more potent, and that exception was being made today. Rebecca added that spankings had never been inflicted in front of anyone outside the family until today, but she was making an exception for obvious reasons.

As Emily began to blush, she miserably listened to the consequences of her actions and Rebecca went on to say that most spankings in the house had been inflicted by her and Alan's open hand, and the belt was reserved for the very rare occasion a teenager committed a heinous offense that warranted a spanking, but today the 11-year-old girl who bullied my son for months would be receiving a belting, because Rebecca was certain Emily's actions had caused Liam to shed tears, so he was going to see her crying as retribution for all the pain she had caused him. I saw Alan Jr and Jackie shuffle in their seats at this announcement, indicating this was an extreme measure. Emily shut her eyes tight in abject distress, but there was one final austere, very harsh aspect of the impending punishment to be announced.

Rebecca stated that in the vast majority of instances, pants would come down and spankings were inflicted over an underwear clad bottom, but if her children sufficiently displeased her or their father they had been spanked on their bare bottom to increase both pain and embarrassment. Emily's eyes shot open, and Rebecca stared her down as she told us that on the very most rare of occasions, so rare they could be counted on one hand, her children had been exposed and spanked naked below the waist there in the living room in front of the family. These were situations where the misbehavior was so egregious and so shameful, the punishment called for immense embarrassment to be deliberately inflicted.

Emily was silently begging her mother for mercy, her cheeks now blushing furiously, but Rebecca confirmed that this was the most immoral, obscene thing any of her children had ever done, and as a result Emily would suffer a proportionate, very memorable consequence. Rebecca looked Emily in the eye and officially sentenced her to what Rebecca called "The Ultimate Punishment" which was a very painful public humiliation.

She was going to be whipped with a belt a dozen times right there in front of everybody, including the boy she took so much pleasure in bullying for so long. She was going to stand, facing my son with her hands on her head while she took her spanking, and to ensure she felt the shame and embarrassment she had inflicted on my son, she was going to be forced to take off both her shorts and underwear to be punished naked from the waist down.

I remember there were two audible gasps, I think from Jackie and Ethan. Alan Jr shuffled in his seat. All of Emily's siblings were wide-eyed, and while it seemed like they knew the punishment was going to be severe, I don't think they knew their sister's nakedness was going to be exposed to my son, nor that she was going to suffer the belt. Jackie actually started to plead to Rebecca on behalf of Emily but Rebecca responded with a thunderous "SILENCE."

You could see tears well up in Emily's eyes as her cheeks blushed redder than I think I've ever seen on any face. Absolute mortification, well deserved. I was certain she was going to cry on the spot, but she somehow held it together even while her mother rubbed salt into wounds.

Rebecca revealed that she had gotten my permission for Liam to watch the spanking despite the forced nudity and she made it clear that for this punishment, Emily's modesty was deliberately being completely disregarded. Embarrassment from the exposure and pain from the belt on bare skin were equally important factors. Rebecca stated that she was not surprised that Emily was blushing, and justified the punishment gloriously: "you took pleasure embarrassing this boy and making him cry, now he's gonna see you crying and he's gonna get a good, long look at your naked lower half, front and back. As a matter of fact, the whole family is." She said that she was going to get the belt from the upstairs bedroom, and while she was gone Emily ought to think about what she did and the humiliation she was about to experience as a result. Rebecca instructed Emily to have her jean shorts down and completely off by the time she returned or she'd be getting more than a dozen licks.

She started to sob to Alan for mercy but Alan put her to shame by merely repeating her actions to her. She physically hurt Liam multiple times, poured liquids on him, tried to shove his head into a toilet (he really emphasized that one). He admonished her her for being cowardly. Alan firmly stated that because she tried to take away my son's dignity, her punishment would involve no dignity whatsoever. He emphasized that the impending spanking was going to be very painful and extremely embarrassing, and if she ever tried to hurt Liam again, he would only need to remind her that he saw her spanked in nothing but a T-shirt. He then reminded her that she better start undressing before Rebecca returned. That got her moving. She stood up and after a brief hesitation, the girl stepped out of the shorts revealing purple boyshorts and long legs. She rubbed one bare foot against the other and took a split second glance at my son, who sat up straight in his seat next to me.

This was the first time my son even moved since he sat down. He had been completely silent the whole time but was no doubt enjoying his bully's comeuppance immensely. After less than a minute Rebecca returned with a thick leather belt, and snapped it loud which caused tears to finally stream down Emily's beet red cheeks. Rebecca said that anyone who wants to leave is allowed to, and Jackie took the opportunity, saying she didn't want to see any more of it. Emily begged Alan Jr to leave as well, but the young man brazenly said with a straight face "No. I want to watch. You were happy enough to watch me." Rebecca said that in that case, it was time to make her bottom as red as her face was. I took the opportunity to ask Emily one thing: what did Liam ever do to you?

There was no answer, and I told her that's exactly what I thought. I told Rebecca to go ahead. She then did something I didn't expect, and asked Liam if he'd ever seen a girl naked before. While Emily shut her eyes tight, my son gave an answer I also didn't expect: he had! I asked him if he meant a girl his age, but he said no. For all I know he probably meant me, but I haven't pressed him on that answer (yet). Rebecca told him to not be afraid to stare. Finally, she gave Emily the command to take off her underwear and step out of them.

The hapless girl took about 10 seconds putting her hands in her waistband, and then quickly pushed them down. This briefly exposed her genitals before she modestly covered them with her hands. Her mother then gave her the fateful order to stand up straight with her feet apart, and put her hands on her head. Reluctantly, with her chest heaving in stress and abject mortification, she managed to obey. Emily placed her hands behind her head, revealing her bald vulva to the room.

To be honest, I think just having her stand like that for a minute or two would have been a fitting punishment without the pain that came after her private parts were made public, but she would not be so lucky and Rebecca struck Emily's bare buttocks with the belt. The cracking sound rang across the room and sounded unbelievably painful. I fully expected her to cry out and tears to start openly flowing but they didn't, and they still didn't after the belt hit her a second time. WHACK!

They still didn't after the third whack, nor the fourth or fifth, nor the sixth or seventh or eighth. WHACK!! Every 5 seconds Rebecca belted Emily's bottom, and each successive blow increased in power. The sounds of the belt punishing bare skin and small sounds coming from Emily were all you could hear over that minute of severe punishment. On the tenth whip of the belt, Emily made a painful whimper, but caught her breath. Rebecca winded up for the eleventh spank and whipped Emily hard as can be which almost sent Emily over the edge, but she caught her breath. Rebecca, with all her might, whipped Emily one last time. WHACK!!! Emily almost lost her balance but kept her footing, and despite the painful belt whipping she let an audible sound of pain go, but exhaled, caught her breath, and opened her eyes which were filled with tears. Rebecca looked very frustrated. She had somehow survived all 12 licks of the extremely painful public spanking without crying out in pain or even the shame of it all.

Or so we all thought. Alan stood up and quickly approached Emily, her hands still behind her head. I heard him muttering something under his breath about how she thinks she's a brave, tough girl, and I remember as he grabbed her forearm and pulled her over to the seat she had been sitting on when she was sentenced to this humiliation, he said "now you're gonna get it." Rebecca and Alan had been very clear that not only did they intend to force Emily to bare her genitals, they intended to force her to cry in pain. As Rebecca stepped back and Alan threw his half naked tween daughter over his lap for a hand spanking, revealing her cherry red bottom to me and my son's eyes for the first time, there was absolutely no doubt that many real tears would be erupting from Emily's eyes very soon.

SMACK! A different painful sound, this time of skin spanking skin, rang out across the room. A couple seconds later Alan again brought his bare hand down hard on Emily's bare ass, targeting the same buttock. He spanked the same buttock again, and Emily inhaled air deep into her lungs. Alan painfully spanked the same buttock a third time, a fourth time a second later even harder, and with the fifth quick-fire spank to the same spot, Emily completely erupted.

Her scream was haunting, but when Emily finally cried out my son sort of played drums on his knees with his hands, clearly delighted with what he was witnessing. Tears streamed freely down Emily's cheeks as she cried out in pain, absolutely bawling as Alan continued the spanking with 5 more quickfire smacks to Emily's other buttock... and the punishment was still not yet complete. Emily once again deeply inhaled and let out a wail of anguish, crying involuntary as a natural plea for mercy.

The pathetic howling fell on deaf ears as Alan continued to bring his hand up, and down very hard onto Emily's buttocks, now alternating between her right and left butt cheek, taking his time and spanking her very hard every few seconds, nice and slow but very forceful. The smacking sound continued to ring out across the room, but it was now accompanied by the sound of Emily roaring in unbearable pain and submission. She screamed, and her father smacked. She screamed, and wailed, and screamed, and cried, and screamed until her father spanked her bare bottom for the 20th time.

He stood her up, looked her directly in her weeping eyes with tears streaming down her face and told her that she would never be involved with any form of bullying ever again or the consequences would be worse. She was told to go to her room and Alan gave her one final very hard spank with his hand, causing her to cry out and run off.

Liam shouted after her "See you tomorrow Emily!" That was the last thing he said other than farewells, and there really was nothing more for him to say. There was a brief moment of silence that I broke by saying that I think she's sorry now. Ethan, who had been smiling the whole time, declared that what he had just witnessed was "cool" and ran off when Alan shot him a glare. Rebecca turned toward Alan Jr and asked if he was satisfied, and it then became clear that the most recent living room bare bottom spanking in front of the family was suffered by the boy a year prior, a punishment inflicted with Rebecca's hand which was overtly and excessively enjoyed by Emily.

Alan Jr said it was worth the wait, and wondered if Emily though the bullying she inflicted on Liam was worth it. I said there was not a chance, and Rebecca said that now she knows full well what the punishment for such behavior would be. The whole family did, in fact. With that, it was time to go home.

[mars357]

A brilliant story of punishment and comeuppance---my absolute favourite theme. It feels like a one-off, but I would be curious if she tried to take her anger out on Liam at some point and got caught again, what that might lead to

[Jetsfan]

I always enjoy a story about a bully getting properly punished. Having her victim watch her is perfect payback. Perhaps the victim should have been given the opportunity to deliver a couple of swats with the strap.
Well written story.