Dare Me - Chapter 17 - Little Sister, Big Sister (Part 14)
Posted: Sun Apr 07, 2024 2:19 pm
After that last peek, I didn't care anymore if Hanna was Lucy's closest friend or if Lucy had forbidden me from pursuing her. Her flirting had worked too well, and I was being driven wild with lust. In the blink of an eye, I abandoned the idea of behaving for Lucy's sake, and let my libido take over calling the shots.
My immediate goal was figuring out a way to signal to Hanna my desire to escalate the sexual tension already building between us without Lucy figuring out I was doing it. I would have to be very strategic with my actions. I couldn't directly reciprocate Hanna's flirtatious advances or respond with anything so obvious that it would make Lucy grow suspicious.
Luckily, by sheer chance, I already had prepared the perfect way to engage in a little, suggestive flirting of my own. I just had to activate my sister and she would willingly play along. She had even already agreed to be an unknowing facilitator in this endeavor.
With the game ending, and since it was nearly lunch time, I offered to make everyone sandwiches. Our garden was at the end of its productive season, but you could still sometimes find a few stragglers here and there. I asked Hanna if she would mind cleaning up the game so Lucy and I could go into the kitchen and discuss fresh vegetable options.
Secretly, I just needed to talk to Lucy in private. As soon as we were alone in the kitchen, I made Lucy pay attention and sternly reminded her of her duty. She hadn't exactly committed to maneuvering Hanna into somehow getting spanked at my hand, but she had agreed to try and would be rewarded with a break from her own humiliating tasks for the rest of the weekend if she succeeded.
Lucy seemed a little hazy on the details of our deal – for good reason. She had been naked and squirming while I traced lazy circles around the outside of her throbbing pussy when the particulars were being discussed. But when I confidently told her that it was time to deliver, she nodded along like she understood.
While I went about preparing the sandwiches in the kitchen, Lucy went into the backyard to gather some vegetables to go with lunch. When Hanna had finished packing up the game, she went out to assist her friend.
Our air conditioner had finally quit working. But since the house was usually empty during the day, we were surviving by opening the windows at night to let in the cooler air or running the ceiling fans. Today would probably be the last hot day of the year. So, we could tough it out a little longer until fall brought cooler weather. Since I oversaw the family budget, I had started setting aside some money in the hopes of having enough saved up to fix our A/C before next summer rolled around.
Because the window over the sink was open to let in a breeze, while I worked, I was able to eavesdrop on the girls talking to each other through the screen. When Hanna knocked something over, maybe a rake or shovel, I heard its handle scrape against the slats of the fence.
"Woah, careful with that," Lucy warned, "you don't want to get a spanking from Mikey."
"...what are you talking about," Hanna asked, genuinely befuddled by that out of the blue comment, and by the entire subject being so randomly broached.
"Oh, come on," Lucy replied, incredulously, "don't act like you've never been spanked before."
"That's not...wait, did you just say, 'from Mikey'?"
"Yeah," Lucy explained, in a professorial, very matter-of-fact, tone, "it's not that strange. Who normally spanks you?"
"Well, my dad sometimes spanks my brothers. He used to spank me, too, but that was when I was a lot younger. He hasn't done that in years," she answered.
Shifting to a wistful, almost forlorn tone, Lucy said, "well, you know my dad's gone. And since she didn't have anyone to help with things like that, mom asked Mikey if he would fill in, once he was old enough. You know, since he's the man of the house. He's even spanked her before."
"What?!" Hanna exclaimed, "Mikey actually spanked your mom?"
"Don't worry, she deserved it," Lucy was quick to add, as if that would explain everything.
"You're joking, right?" Hanna asked, "You’re not serious."
"Don't believe me? Fine, I'll prove it to you!"
...SLAP!
I was so surprised by the sound of Lucy hitting Hanna that I nearly cut myself with the knife I was holding. Since I couldn't see anything from where I was standing, I moved closer to the window, leaning far over the sink so I could see them by peeking through the blinds.
Lucy had squared up on her friend, standing defiantly just a couple feet away. Hanna stood facing her, looking shocked and confused. From the way she was rubbing her right cheek, I guessed that's where Lucy had slapped her.
"OW! Lucy, that hurt!" she cried out.
"Go ahead, tattle on me. You'll see," Lucy challenged.
After a few seconds, when nothing happened, Lucy wound up and slapped her on her other cheek, hard enough to show she wasn't messing around.
"OOOW. Stop that, I'm serious!" Hanna complained.
"If you want me to stop, then go tell Mikey."
But loyal Hanna still refused to tattle on her best friend. Unfortunately, because she had moved her hands over to rub her left cheek, her right cheek was once again exposed. You can probably guess what happened next.
...SLAP!
"YEOW! OK, FINE!"
A few seconds later, Hanna came charging through the back door into the kitchen rubbing both her cheeks. By then I had gone back to the sandwiches and did my best to look like I had no idea what had just transpired. Smug Lucy marched in as well, pulling the door closed behind her. Hanna, quite incensed by this point, blurted out her accusation.
"Mikey, Lucy hit me!"
"What?!" I feigned shock even though I had seen it happen through the window. By now I had figured out what Lucy was up to. This was the first step in her clever entrapment scheme. Slapping your houseguest repeatedly and without being provoked was clearly out of bounds. So, Hanna couldn't possibly disagree that some consequence was in order.
Now that she had been briefed on how our family deals with naughty behavior, Hanna shouldn't be surprised by what was about to happen. But if she stood by and let Lucy willingly submit herself to a spanking from her own brother to atone for her actions, the trap would be set. Lucy just had to later catch Hanna misbehaving and Hanna would be obligated by the precedent Lucy had already established. Whether a future consequence would rise to the level of a full-blown spanking would be up to whomever was in charge. I'll give you one guess who was in charge!
Slipping into the role of both justice of the peace and family disciplinarian, I pulled my shoulders back and stepped forward to inspect Hanna's face so I could decide for myself how to proceed. My sister had not held back. Both the poor girl's cheeks had gotten pretty rosy in a very short amount of time. They were almost as red as her pouty lips! I couldn't help but wonder if her bottom would have a similar reaction after a few forceful impacts.
Pretending to make up my mind, I spoke. "You don't look hurt, Hanna, but hitting someone in anger is never ok. Just like anyone staying under this roof, Lucy is expected to follow our family rules. And if she doesn't, she has to accept the consequences of breaking them."
Turning to my sister, I pointed at the breakfast table, and said, "Lucy, put your elbows on the table."
When it registered with Hanna what I intended to do, she felt a twinge of regret and tried to smooth things over instead.
"It-It's ok, really," she insisted, dropping her hands to her side as if to signal that she was willing to forgive Lucy's misconduct and drop the matter altogether, "you don't have to-"
"NO!" I cut her off with a forceful tone, "Lucy knows better than to hit her friends. This is unacceptable."
The time for debating was over. Having issued my final ruling, I stood firm with my arm still extended, and waited for Lucy to comply with my order. The standoff ended when Lucy silently walked to the table, bent over at the waist, and placed her elbows on the surface.
With her bottom now in prime spanking position, I came over to stand behind her. Seeing my shadow fall over her made her start to squirm. Hanna made a soft gasp when, without hesitation, I lifted the back of Lucy's shirt a little so I could get access to the waistband of her play shorts. She had just come to terms with the idea of Lucy being spanked at the hands of her own big brother. But nobody had informed her that spankings in the Jenkins household are always done on bare bottoms.
Reaching down with both my hands, I grabbed Lucy’s shorts and her panties together and slid them out of the way. I kept my face stern and did not react to the erotic sight of her bare, wiggling rump. Lucy had been speaking the truth when she said I was in charge of our family's spankings. I had only done it a sparingly, and only because Lucy's behavior had gotten really out of control.
I didn't want to make a spectacle of it. Rather, I wanted the whole thing to come across as just another chore, something I was only doing because I had to. But because I had an audience watching, I felt like I should at least make a little show out of it.
"Lucy, I hope you know that this is going to hurt me more than it hurts you," I said, in a patronizing voice. It was something I had heard from tv when the kids get spanked by their parents.
Then, without further ceremony, I spanked her directly on her bottom, three times in quick succession, one for each time she had slapped her friend. My wind-ups were swift and elaborate, but my open palm landed on her bottom as lightly as I could make it while still generating a moderately loud sound. The way Lucy legitimately yipped like I was beating the living daylights out of her did most of the heavy lifting making it believable enough.
Seeing I was finished, Lucy started to stand up, but I caught her by the back of her head and told her to stay put. As the stinging sensation spread, she started doing her little pain dance, lifting her feet one at a time and flexing the strong muscles of her bottom in a futile effort to ease the ache in her booty.
"Now apologize to your friend," I ordered.
With her shorts and panties still around her legs and her flexing bottom still completely bared, Lucy turned her head as best she could without getting out of her bent over position and located Hanna. Her eyes had welled up with real tears, but the smirk on her face was saying, "I told you so."
"Sorry," she muttered, resentfully. When Hanna replied with, "it's ok", I finally allowed Lucy to stand up and fix her shorts.
Lucy led her friend back outside where they finished picking vegetables. I returned to the kitchen with a smile on my face and a tent in my shorts. Lucy had played her hand masterfully, establishing our family's spanking precedent and setting the trap for unsuspecting Hanna. All she had to do now was catch her friend doing something against our "house rules" and bring her to me for punishment.
It took her until the middle of the afternoon. After we had eaten lunch, I helpfully put the dishes away and cleaned up the kitchen while the girls wandered off to play somewhere else. I was ok keeping my distance. Because Hanna was still without her bra, I had a hard time concentrating on her face when I was around her. My gaze kept drifting down to study the soft fabric of her top. I was a blackbelt by then at undressing girls with my mind and the way her lightweight tee shirt draped suggestively over the tender swells of her chest made too easy a target for my uncontrollable eyes.
Assuming my disciplinary services would be called upon any minute, I kept my nerves in check with busy work. Taking all the mail that had accumulated over the course of the week into the dining room, I spread out the stacks of past-due bills on the table and began to sort through them. The hardship exceptions I had successfully applied for from the utility companies were expiring. That made this already undesirable chore even more crummy. When the girls did eventually return to me with another conflict, I didn't have to pretend too hard to be in a bad, unforgiving mood.
When I heard Lucy cry out from a distance, my heart skipped a beat. Was this the moment? Pretty soon, I heard them stampeding down the stairs with Lucy wailing the whole time.
She arrived at the dining room first, holding one of her favorite blouses. Hanna charged in a little behind her, looking understandably nervous. Both girls were wearing different clothes than what they had had on earlier. At some point, while up in Lucy's room playing dress-up, Hanna had put a bra back on. That made it easier for me to focus on my role in this mediation.
"Mikeeeeee, she tore it...on purpose!" Lucy exclaimed, holding up the blouse to show a big tear in the seam down one side.
"It was an accident," Hanna rushed to explain, "I'm sorry."
"It was not an accident," Lucy accused, between big, wet sniffles, "you wouldn't let go and now you ruined it!"
Turning to me, she whined, "Mikeeey, she said she was jealous of it. That's why she tore it. She didn't want me to have it."
Putting on a judicial facade, I crossed my arms seriously and asked, "Hanna, did you really say that?"
"No!," she stammered, before clarifying, "well, I didn't mean it like that." Turning back to her friend, she added, "and I was trying to take it off just like you asked. You just yanked on it before I could give it to you."
I had enough information to piece together what had happened. Lucy had ripped the shirt herself while Hanna was taking it off to make it look like they had been wrestling over it. She wanted me to conclude that Hanna's jealous resistance had led to the tear. As spankable offences went, there wasn't much there. Lucy had not given me enough of a conflict to justify spanking her friend. Luckily, perhaps coming to the same conclusion, she added one last grievance.
"And she called me fat!"
Hanna flinched, but quickly recovered and defended herself. "That was just a joke, and you know it!"
The girls glared at each other for a tense moment. Hanna couldn't figure out where all this animosity from Lucy was coming from. First the slaps and now this? Why had her friend turned on her so suddenly?
"I just don't know what has gotten into you girls today," I wondered aloud, "you usually get along so well."
I took the shirt from Lucy and studied it before continuing, "I can't help but wonder if this was your way of getting back at Lucy for hitting you earlier."
Hanna opened her mouth to refute the theory, but I cut her off sternly. Their time to talk was over. Now it was my turn.
"Either way, we do not allow name-calling in this house," I said, my voice dripping with regret. Seeing that I had already made up my mind to punish her, Hanna's shoulders slumped, knowing what was coming next.
Extending my arm and pointing my finger like the grim reaper, I said, "I'm sorry, Hanna. Elbows on the table."
My immediate goal was figuring out a way to signal to Hanna my desire to escalate the sexual tension already building between us without Lucy figuring out I was doing it. I would have to be very strategic with my actions. I couldn't directly reciprocate Hanna's flirtatious advances or respond with anything so obvious that it would make Lucy grow suspicious.
Luckily, by sheer chance, I already had prepared the perfect way to engage in a little, suggestive flirting of my own. I just had to activate my sister and she would willingly play along. She had even already agreed to be an unknowing facilitator in this endeavor.
With the game ending, and since it was nearly lunch time, I offered to make everyone sandwiches. Our garden was at the end of its productive season, but you could still sometimes find a few stragglers here and there. I asked Hanna if she would mind cleaning up the game so Lucy and I could go into the kitchen and discuss fresh vegetable options.
Secretly, I just needed to talk to Lucy in private. As soon as we were alone in the kitchen, I made Lucy pay attention and sternly reminded her of her duty. She hadn't exactly committed to maneuvering Hanna into somehow getting spanked at my hand, but she had agreed to try and would be rewarded with a break from her own humiliating tasks for the rest of the weekend if she succeeded.
Lucy seemed a little hazy on the details of our deal – for good reason. She had been naked and squirming while I traced lazy circles around the outside of her throbbing pussy when the particulars were being discussed. But when I confidently told her that it was time to deliver, she nodded along like she understood.
While I went about preparing the sandwiches in the kitchen, Lucy went into the backyard to gather some vegetables to go with lunch. When Hanna had finished packing up the game, she went out to assist her friend.
Our air conditioner had finally quit working. But since the house was usually empty during the day, we were surviving by opening the windows at night to let in the cooler air or running the ceiling fans. Today would probably be the last hot day of the year. So, we could tough it out a little longer until fall brought cooler weather. Since I oversaw the family budget, I had started setting aside some money in the hopes of having enough saved up to fix our A/C before next summer rolled around.
Because the window over the sink was open to let in a breeze, while I worked, I was able to eavesdrop on the girls talking to each other through the screen. When Hanna knocked something over, maybe a rake or shovel, I heard its handle scrape against the slats of the fence.
"Woah, careful with that," Lucy warned, "you don't want to get a spanking from Mikey."
"...what are you talking about," Hanna asked, genuinely befuddled by that out of the blue comment, and by the entire subject being so randomly broached.
"Oh, come on," Lucy replied, incredulously, "don't act like you've never been spanked before."
"That's not...wait, did you just say, 'from Mikey'?"
"Yeah," Lucy explained, in a professorial, very matter-of-fact, tone, "it's not that strange. Who normally spanks you?"
"Well, my dad sometimes spanks my brothers. He used to spank me, too, but that was when I was a lot younger. He hasn't done that in years," she answered.
Shifting to a wistful, almost forlorn tone, Lucy said, "well, you know my dad's gone. And since she didn't have anyone to help with things like that, mom asked Mikey if he would fill in, once he was old enough. You know, since he's the man of the house. He's even spanked her before."
"What?!" Hanna exclaimed, "Mikey actually spanked your mom?"
"Don't worry, she deserved it," Lucy was quick to add, as if that would explain everything.
"You're joking, right?" Hanna asked, "You’re not serious."
"Don't believe me? Fine, I'll prove it to you!"
...SLAP!
I was so surprised by the sound of Lucy hitting Hanna that I nearly cut myself with the knife I was holding. Since I couldn't see anything from where I was standing, I moved closer to the window, leaning far over the sink so I could see them by peeking through the blinds.
Lucy had squared up on her friend, standing defiantly just a couple feet away. Hanna stood facing her, looking shocked and confused. From the way she was rubbing her right cheek, I guessed that's where Lucy had slapped her.
"OW! Lucy, that hurt!" she cried out.
"Go ahead, tattle on me. You'll see," Lucy challenged.
After a few seconds, when nothing happened, Lucy wound up and slapped her on her other cheek, hard enough to show she wasn't messing around.
"OOOW. Stop that, I'm serious!" Hanna complained.
"If you want me to stop, then go tell Mikey."
But loyal Hanna still refused to tattle on her best friend. Unfortunately, because she had moved her hands over to rub her left cheek, her right cheek was once again exposed. You can probably guess what happened next.
...SLAP!
"YEOW! OK, FINE!"
A few seconds later, Hanna came charging through the back door into the kitchen rubbing both her cheeks. By then I had gone back to the sandwiches and did my best to look like I had no idea what had just transpired. Smug Lucy marched in as well, pulling the door closed behind her. Hanna, quite incensed by this point, blurted out her accusation.
"Mikey, Lucy hit me!"
"What?!" I feigned shock even though I had seen it happen through the window. By now I had figured out what Lucy was up to. This was the first step in her clever entrapment scheme. Slapping your houseguest repeatedly and without being provoked was clearly out of bounds. So, Hanna couldn't possibly disagree that some consequence was in order.
Now that she had been briefed on how our family deals with naughty behavior, Hanna shouldn't be surprised by what was about to happen. But if she stood by and let Lucy willingly submit herself to a spanking from her own brother to atone for her actions, the trap would be set. Lucy just had to later catch Hanna misbehaving and Hanna would be obligated by the precedent Lucy had already established. Whether a future consequence would rise to the level of a full-blown spanking would be up to whomever was in charge. I'll give you one guess who was in charge!
Slipping into the role of both justice of the peace and family disciplinarian, I pulled my shoulders back and stepped forward to inspect Hanna's face so I could decide for myself how to proceed. My sister had not held back. Both the poor girl's cheeks had gotten pretty rosy in a very short amount of time. They were almost as red as her pouty lips! I couldn't help but wonder if her bottom would have a similar reaction after a few forceful impacts.
Pretending to make up my mind, I spoke. "You don't look hurt, Hanna, but hitting someone in anger is never ok. Just like anyone staying under this roof, Lucy is expected to follow our family rules. And if she doesn't, she has to accept the consequences of breaking them."
Turning to my sister, I pointed at the breakfast table, and said, "Lucy, put your elbows on the table."
When it registered with Hanna what I intended to do, she felt a twinge of regret and tried to smooth things over instead.
"It-It's ok, really," she insisted, dropping her hands to her side as if to signal that she was willing to forgive Lucy's misconduct and drop the matter altogether, "you don't have to-"
"NO!" I cut her off with a forceful tone, "Lucy knows better than to hit her friends. This is unacceptable."
The time for debating was over. Having issued my final ruling, I stood firm with my arm still extended, and waited for Lucy to comply with my order. The standoff ended when Lucy silently walked to the table, bent over at the waist, and placed her elbows on the surface.
With her bottom now in prime spanking position, I came over to stand behind her. Seeing my shadow fall over her made her start to squirm. Hanna made a soft gasp when, without hesitation, I lifted the back of Lucy's shirt a little so I could get access to the waistband of her play shorts. She had just come to terms with the idea of Lucy being spanked at the hands of her own big brother. But nobody had informed her that spankings in the Jenkins household are always done on bare bottoms.
Reaching down with both my hands, I grabbed Lucy’s shorts and her panties together and slid them out of the way. I kept my face stern and did not react to the erotic sight of her bare, wiggling rump. Lucy had been speaking the truth when she said I was in charge of our family's spankings. I had only done it a sparingly, and only because Lucy's behavior had gotten really out of control.
I didn't want to make a spectacle of it. Rather, I wanted the whole thing to come across as just another chore, something I was only doing because I had to. But because I had an audience watching, I felt like I should at least make a little show out of it.
"Lucy, I hope you know that this is going to hurt me more than it hurts you," I said, in a patronizing voice. It was something I had heard from tv when the kids get spanked by their parents.
Then, without further ceremony, I spanked her directly on her bottom, three times in quick succession, one for each time she had slapped her friend. My wind-ups were swift and elaborate, but my open palm landed on her bottom as lightly as I could make it while still generating a moderately loud sound. The way Lucy legitimately yipped like I was beating the living daylights out of her did most of the heavy lifting making it believable enough.
Seeing I was finished, Lucy started to stand up, but I caught her by the back of her head and told her to stay put. As the stinging sensation spread, she started doing her little pain dance, lifting her feet one at a time and flexing the strong muscles of her bottom in a futile effort to ease the ache in her booty.
"Now apologize to your friend," I ordered.
With her shorts and panties still around her legs and her flexing bottom still completely bared, Lucy turned her head as best she could without getting out of her bent over position and located Hanna. Her eyes had welled up with real tears, but the smirk on her face was saying, "I told you so."
"Sorry," she muttered, resentfully. When Hanna replied with, "it's ok", I finally allowed Lucy to stand up and fix her shorts.
Lucy led her friend back outside where they finished picking vegetables. I returned to the kitchen with a smile on my face and a tent in my shorts. Lucy had played her hand masterfully, establishing our family's spanking precedent and setting the trap for unsuspecting Hanna. All she had to do now was catch her friend doing something against our "house rules" and bring her to me for punishment.
It took her until the middle of the afternoon. After we had eaten lunch, I helpfully put the dishes away and cleaned up the kitchen while the girls wandered off to play somewhere else. I was ok keeping my distance. Because Hanna was still without her bra, I had a hard time concentrating on her face when I was around her. My gaze kept drifting down to study the soft fabric of her top. I was a blackbelt by then at undressing girls with my mind and the way her lightweight tee shirt draped suggestively over the tender swells of her chest made too easy a target for my uncontrollable eyes.
Assuming my disciplinary services would be called upon any minute, I kept my nerves in check with busy work. Taking all the mail that had accumulated over the course of the week into the dining room, I spread out the stacks of past-due bills on the table and began to sort through them. The hardship exceptions I had successfully applied for from the utility companies were expiring. That made this already undesirable chore even more crummy. When the girls did eventually return to me with another conflict, I didn't have to pretend too hard to be in a bad, unforgiving mood.
When I heard Lucy cry out from a distance, my heart skipped a beat. Was this the moment? Pretty soon, I heard them stampeding down the stairs with Lucy wailing the whole time.
She arrived at the dining room first, holding one of her favorite blouses. Hanna charged in a little behind her, looking understandably nervous. Both girls were wearing different clothes than what they had had on earlier. At some point, while up in Lucy's room playing dress-up, Hanna had put a bra back on. That made it easier for me to focus on my role in this mediation.
"Mikeeeeee, she tore it...on purpose!" Lucy exclaimed, holding up the blouse to show a big tear in the seam down one side.
"It was an accident," Hanna rushed to explain, "I'm sorry."
"It was not an accident," Lucy accused, between big, wet sniffles, "you wouldn't let go and now you ruined it!"
Turning to me, she whined, "Mikeeey, she said she was jealous of it. That's why she tore it. She didn't want me to have it."
Putting on a judicial facade, I crossed my arms seriously and asked, "Hanna, did you really say that?"
"No!," she stammered, before clarifying, "well, I didn't mean it like that." Turning back to her friend, she added, "and I was trying to take it off just like you asked. You just yanked on it before I could give it to you."
I had enough information to piece together what had happened. Lucy had ripped the shirt herself while Hanna was taking it off to make it look like they had been wrestling over it. She wanted me to conclude that Hanna's jealous resistance had led to the tear. As spankable offences went, there wasn't much there. Lucy had not given me enough of a conflict to justify spanking her friend. Luckily, perhaps coming to the same conclusion, she added one last grievance.
"And she called me fat!"
Hanna flinched, but quickly recovered and defended herself. "That was just a joke, and you know it!"
The girls glared at each other for a tense moment. Hanna couldn't figure out where all this animosity from Lucy was coming from. First the slaps and now this? Why had her friend turned on her so suddenly?
"I just don't know what has gotten into you girls today," I wondered aloud, "you usually get along so well."
I took the shirt from Lucy and studied it before continuing, "I can't help but wonder if this was your way of getting back at Lucy for hitting you earlier."
Hanna opened her mouth to refute the theory, but I cut her off sternly. Their time to talk was over. Now it was my turn.
"Either way, we do not allow name-calling in this house," I said, my voice dripping with regret. Seeing that I had already made up my mind to punish her, Hanna's shoulders slumped, knowing what was coming next.
Extending my arm and pointing my finger like the grim reaper, I said, "I'm sorry, Hanna. Elbows on the table."