My Sisters and Me - Visual Novel Prologue Now Out!

[Pattareth]

I want more

[drew]

I did my best to avoid Katie the next few weeks and I’m sure she did the same. In the moment, it was exciting and taboo, and sexy as hell playing strip games with her. But it was soberingly shameful afterward. It was odd, I never felt this humiliation after my interactions with Maddy. Perhaps because those occurred (mostly) with just us two. Maddy was also much more natural about it.

On the occasions where Katie and I did run into each other, there was mostly awkward silences and glances. But a few weeks later, she was back to her bossy, confident self.

“You’re wearing that?” She gave me a disgusted look as I got ready to leave the house for a date. I was eager to get away from all this “icky” sister shit and hopefully see some non-familial pussy. It had been too long.

“Awww I think he looks cute K!” Maddy said.

“If he’s trying to be the next star of My Big Redneck Wedding,” Katie responded. “You look like a scarecrow.”

Maddy giggled, but interjected. “Stop it! He does not!”

But I actually kind of did. Dressed in a flannel and jeans, all I was missing was a straw hat. I laughed it off.

“Where’d you meet this chick anyway?” Katie asked. “Farmers only dot com?”

“Shut up. Why you so interested anyway?”

“I’m not. Just saying.” She laughed and raised her eyebrows before turning back to whatever show she was watching.

“Bye Drew!” Maddy said.

“C-ya MADDY.” I emphasized her name and gave a mocking look toward Katie, who turned back to me. She returned the look and rolled her eyes as I walked out the door.

Alas, my date went well enough, but she (Jamie) was clearly not a girl who “hooked up.” Not really wanting a full-blown relationship, I let her know. She seemed disappointed but we agreed to be friends. In the past, I may have pushed a little harder, or been vaguer with my intentions. Especially as hot as Jamie was. But it was as if I wasn’t even that interested. And Maddy and Katie kept creeping into my thoughts….God I was fucked up.

I returned home in blah mood. Usually, if I didn’t go home with my date, I would have the urge to watch some porn and jerk off before going to sleep. There’s a lot of restraining urges when trying to make a good first impression. But tonight, I just wasn’t feeling it.

I struggled to fall asleep for a little bit when I noticed the hallway light turn on. Katie’s door opened and she emerged in my sight line. Dressed in only a tiny navy thong, she walked to the bathroom, holding her tits in her hands. Entranced by her sporty ass, I was instantly brought back to the strip-cards night when I saw it bare. She wasn’t in a hurry. Her hips swayed intoxicatingly back and forth as she strutted down the hall. The bathroom door shut behind her and I was stiff as a board. I waited patiently to see what she did.

I heard the sink water running and the bathroom door reopened. Katie made her way directly to my room with a boob in each hand. She looked into my room in a calm, self-assured manner, though I’m not positive she could actually see me. She disappeared around the corner, the light turned off, and that was that. So much for not jerking off, I thought to myself. I finished in about 15 seconds.

[drew]

I typically like to complete my workouts earlier in the morning when the city (and my family) was still asleep. But my unorthodox schedule didn’t always allow for that. It was a chilly autumn afternoon and the leaves crunched beneath my feet as I walk home from a frustrating day at the gym. My routine took me almost triple its usual time with all the d-bags and Instagram chicks hogging the equipment for their selfies. To add insult to injury, the sky clouded over while I was inside and there was now a light rain coming down.

I arrived home to find the condo empty, or so I thought. I peeled my soggy clothing off and entered the shower to clean up. The hot water soothed my foul mood as I let my mind wander. Once I finally had enough, I turned the knob off, and basked in the steam a bit longer. When I pulled the shower curtain, the door to the bathroom suddenly burst open.

“What the hell!?” I jumped a bit, startled. I peeked my head around the corner to see that Maddy had entered the room. I sighed, with relief. “Jesus Maddy, you scared the shit out of me.”

“Sorry!” She said. I still just had my head stretched around the corner. The rest of my body was in the shower, out of her view. “Just need to brush my teeth real quick.”

She applied the paste to her brush, but instead of using it, she began to floss. Slowly, I might add. I awkwardly watched her floss for a bit as the water on my body began to evaporate, giving me goosebumps. My towel was hung on the wall opposite the shower. I would need to step into my sister’s eye line to grab it.

Fuck it. I thought to myself. I cupped my cock and balls in my hand – I certainly didn’t want Maddy to see my package in its current chilled state – and stuck one leg out of the shower. I reached my other arm across the way to grab the towel.

Maddy didn’t hesitate to steal looks at my body while she flossed. I made sure to subtly flex my arm and thigh muscles before pulling the towel back towards me. I turned three quarters the way around. I wanted her to see my back and ass. For whatever reason, girls seemed to compliment that part of me the most. I began to dry off, and gave her a good 10 seconds. I couldn’t see from this position, but I knew she was ogling. In order to catch her, I turned my head in an instant and saw those blue eyes locked below my waist in the mirror. She bashfully looked away, and began looking around the room.

Satisfied, I wrapped the towel around my waist and walked past her. She had finally begun brushing her teeth by this point.

“Bye!” Her voice muffled. She checked out my chest and abs quickly and I shut the door behind me. The post shower events had an even better effect on my mood than the steaming hot water.

[Executionus]

This has been quite fun so far, just a series of awkward horny shenanigans.

[drew]

It had been over a month since Ed and Amy’s party. I hadn’t seen Kelly since, but saw Jordan quite a bit. He never brought up that night. Was probably too embarrassed from being so horned up. And obviously I had no reason to discuss my sister-induced hard-on either. I’m not sure if it was on purpose, but we avoided Ed and that whole side of town as well as the other spots where we frequently ran into the girls.

But time heals all wounds – or in this case, all shame – and we found ourselves at a dive bar that Kelly and Katie loved visiting on Thursday nights.

“Well, well, well look what the cat drug in!” Kelly exclaimed as we entered the bar. We had Dave, the bartender, pour us two beers.

“Ahh you guys finally decided to show your faces back in here huh.” Katie said, in her cocky manner. She and Kelly looked as good as ever, though much more casually dressed this time. Kelly’s hair was in her signature braid and she wore a t-shirt and jeans. Katie had her hair pulled up in a ponytail and was also in jeans, with a sweater on top.

“What’re you guys up to tonight?” I asked.

“Probably just hanging here for a bit. I gotta work tomorrow so nothing too crazy.” Kelly responded. “you?”

“I’m off tonight and tomorrow. Wanted something low key though.”

“Pssssh. Low key. Ha!” She mocked. “You’re off tomorrow. Oie! Dave! Pour this man a shot!”

“Whiskey?” Dave looked at me. I looked at Kelly shaking my head. She smiled back, batting her eyelashes at me. I couldn’t resist.

“Tequila!”

“There he is!” Kelly shouted. Dave poured the drink and I quickly gulped it down.

The night continued, and Katie, Jordan, and myself were succumbed into drinking shot after shot from Kelly. She drank a bit herself, but not nearly the same amount. Eventually, we found ourselves naturally split into pairs. Jordan and Katie flirted in the corner. Myself and Kelly at the bar. There was almost no one else in the building other than Dave.

“So Drew…you seem extra interested in me tonight. What changed from last time?” Kelly asked me. I had my hand on her thigh.

“What do you mean?” I slurred.

“Well, if my memory serves me right, you had a MASSIVE boner after you pulled off Katie’s underwear!” Her grin was ear to ear.

“What!? No!” I lied. I could feel the heat forming in my face. And it wasn’t from the alcohol.

“You did!” Kelly laughed. “I saw it!”

“Okay well one…why were you looking down there?” I tried to turn the tables on her.

“Uh uh. Nope. Not gonna shame me. It’s totally natural for me to check out some dude in only his boxers. But getting hard from your sister’s coochie on the other hand…”

“Shut up! C’mon Kells! You were barely dressed too. And the E was taking affect. I had plenty of reasons to be…have a…you know.”

“I do know.” She teased. “And I’m pretty sure it was just a little chub when I got down to my undies.” She raised her eyebrows at me. “’But full on rager when Katie’s charms were revealed!” She looked over at my sister and Jordan. They were playing pool.

“I…it’s just…” I stuttered. My cheeks were blazing at this point.

“Oh, relax Drew!” Kelly rubbed my back. “I’m just giving you shit!”

“You’re mean!” I said.

“Nah I get it, you can’t control that. It was a pretty wild night. I was…well…I had to get out of there in a hurry or I probably would’ve made some bad decisions.”

“Like…?”

She rolled her eyes at me. “C’mon. Let’s dance.” She walked over to the jukebox and put on some 80s pop playlist.

80s weren’t really my cup of tea, but I was pretty loose by this point, and allowed myself to catch the rhythm as Kelly rubbed her big ass up against me. It didn’t take long for my bulge to swell up under my jeans. Kelly smiled as she felt it, but didn’t say anything. We continued to dance.

Out of the corner of my eye I caught Katie staring at us. She didn’t seem pleased. Not angry or anything, but almost upset? Or…jealous? She made eye contact with me and held my stare as her friend grinded on me. Without a doubt, Katie was bored with Jordan, and he looked pretty frustrated.
Katie watched in silence for a bit longer before coming to her senses. She got up and walked over to us with nice posture and her head held high.

“Alright lovebirds, time to get going.” She said to us.

“Loooooovebirds!” Kelly mocked the title given to her. “Okay!” She quickly stopped dancing on me and kissed my cheek. “See ya around Drew!” She turned to Jordan, who was sulking in the corner. “Bye bro!” He returned a little wave. The girls disappeared just as quickly as they did on the night of the stripping. Jordan didn’t say much to me after, and we both went home a little later.

[drew]

Halloween was nearing. Pumpkins and cornstalks were everywhere I went reminding that I needed to find a costume. There were flyers being handed out promoting various parties taking place across the city. Jordan and I were rummaging through a thrift store, trying to be sparked by an idea.

“This is useless,” I said with frustration. “I need to have an idea in mind so I know what I’m looking for. All this stuff’s just gonna make me look like a hobo if there’s no plan to it.”

“Word. Yeah..and good luck getting some ass dressed as a hobo.” Jordan replied. We agreed to go our separate ways and I walked home. It was an unusually warm day for late October.

I arrived home and saw a note on the counter from my mom saying she’d headed out. The shower was running and Katie was taking an afternoon nap on the couch. Which meant Maddy was in the shower. My turn. I thought devilishly.

Ever since Maddy barged in on me in the bathroom, I waited patiently for the right time to return the favor. I quietly hurried up the stairs, not wanting to wake Katie. My heart rate sped up. The water shut off and I turned the knob, praying she left it unlocked. My prayers were answered and I walked into the room. I turned the sink on, I didn’t want to startle her.

“Oh…hi Drew!” She peaked around the corner in her normal lively manner. “Watcha doin?”

“Hey Maddy. I was gonna get in after you.”

“Ahh okay. I won’t be long.”

I took my shirt off and acted like I was busy.

“Hey don’t look back here for a sec, k? I’m gonna grab my towel.” Maddy said. Her towel was in the same place as my own – on the wall rack across from the shower.

“Got it.” I confirmed.

But c’mon, we were both kidding ourselves at this point. Her right leg stepped out over the tub and onto the floor. It had a golden shine to it from the water. She dropped a hand to shield her vag but let her breasts swing free as she pulled the rest of her body out from around the corner. I only saw side-boob, but it was enough to guess that her tits were as perky as her personality. She glanced over toward me and let out a little laugh when she saw me creeping.

“ahhh!” She let out a cute, quiet little yelp as she now stood completely nude out in the open – though facing me from the side. I welcome the profile view of her bouncy right butt cheek. Cupping her pussy with her right hand, she grabbed the towel with the left, and easily wrapped it around her body.

“Show’s over!” She said.

“what..?” I played dumb.

“Just joking. It’s all yours.” She smiled at me and exited the bathroom.

Before stripping down, I went over the shut the door. I heard Maddy’s voice again, but it was not directed toward me.

“Hey Katie!”

Katie? I thought to myself. I looked out into the hallway to see Katie’s door swinging shut quickly. She hadn’t said anything. Had she just witnessed what happened?

[drew]

Lucky for me, Katie’s jealousy had been kicked up a notch after seeing me flirt with Kelly, and in the bathroom with Maddy. In the past, she would’ve given us TONS of shit had she seen us in the bathroom together again, naked. But now, she didn’t say a word about it. In fact, she didn’t say much at all around me. No jokes, no sarcastic remarks, no bossing me around.

Nonetheless, she had discovered how to get my attention. She was wearing less and less around the house. She even walked around in only a towel on a few occasions – when mom wasn’t around of course.

Maddy’s reaction to Katie’s behavior was interesting. The first time her big sister walked out to the kitchen in a towel, Maddy and I were sitting on the couch and I was helping her do her homework.

Katie didn’t have it in her to pull off the same “innocent” routine that Maddy did so expertly. She didn’t giggle or laugh or smile. She would just walk out, grab whatever she was looking for, maybe bend over a bit. But that was it.

Maddy watched her curiously. Almost as if she was studying her.

And Katie continued to push the boundaries. One night, when she knew I’d be awake, she pulled the same hallway routine as before. But this time, she did it completely naked. It was hard to see, because she didn’t turn the light on, but I was almost positive there was no thong or anything when I saw her ass jiggle down the hallway. On her way back, it was confirmed. My eyes had adjusted to the light and I got a quick glimpse of shadows and smoothness before she splayed her fingers to cover. She kept her chest covered much to my dismay. I was dying to see her cans. It seemed I just needed to make her a bit more jealous. Ironically, it was Katie herself who ended up giving me the opportunity to do so.

Maddy was a quick learner, and it only took Katie doing it a few times before she tried the towel move out herself. It was a lazy Sunday and Katie and I were lounging around. Maddy was in the shower. I didn’t dare creep on her with Katie wide awake right next to me. But I did notice Katie glance in my direction when the water turned off.

“What?” I asked.

“Nothing.” She replied. She went back to looking at her phone.

Before we knew it, guess who came waltzing down the stairs in only her towel. Maddy’s auburn hair was wet and now more of a brown color as it cascaded down to the top of the cotton.

“Forgot my phone.” She blushed when we looked her way. She pranced out to the coffee table where her phone (conveniently) lay. I tracked her movements and she laughed, but then I saw Katie. Her eyes burned with annoyance as her competition not only stole her move, but had the audacity do it right in front of her. I could feel something was about to go down.

“Ya know Mads, if you wanna hold his interest, you gotta eventually let him see something.”

“Huh?” Maddy turned to face her older sister, but she was too late.

With one swift motion, Katie whisked the towel away from Maddy. She took off up the stairs.

“Ohmygosh!” Maddy squealed. I got a quick bare butt shot before she turned to face me. She was frustratingly fast at draping one arm across her breasts and the other over her crotch. I guess she had plenty of practice by now. She wasn’t tense, her hands and arms lazily shielding her privates. I stared.

“Drew! Don’t look!” She said. But her facial expression told me otherwise.

She made zero attempt to escape her situation. She stuck out her bottom lip in a faux-pouting display. “Can you get my towel for me?” she asked.

“uhhh” I didn’t want to move as my dick was as hard as ever. She looked amazing, with her tanned, toned body barely covered. She wore a shy, lively grin.

“I mean, you just gonna stare or….”

I stood up, and didn’t bother to adjust myself. Maddy looked ecstatic at the tent in my shorts.

“Ummmm…” was all she said as she moved her eyes up and away, and then back to my cock, and then away again. It seemed she was almost more embarrassed for me and my stiffy than she was standing there in the nude.

I made a motion toward the stairs when I saw Katie’s ferocious gaze, like a lioness. Her eyes locked onto my boner but she didn’t have the amusement on her face like she did when I pulled her panties down that glorious night which felt so long ago.

And then, all hell broke loose. A key shoved into the front door, the knob turned, and the door swung open.

“Oh shit!” I heard Maddy whisper, behind me. Her playfulness was instantly replaced with fear. But she had nowhere to go. She was trapped behind me and the furniture. She stood exposed in the middle of the living room with her arms now pressed desperately against her privates.

“WHAT THE HELL DO YOU THINK YOU’RE DOING!” Our mom’s voice boomed into the room from the kitchen.

“Oh my!” our aunt Nancy stood beside her.

It was a ridiculous scene. I raced to cover my hard-on but it was too late. Both my mom and aunt saw me standing only a few feet away from my bare-naked sister with my dick pointed at the ceiling. I saw Katie scurry further up the stairs, towel still in hand.

“FOR HEAVEN’S SAKE, HOW MANY TIMES ARE YOU GONNA DO THIS MADELINE?!” My mom dropped her bags and marched over to Maddy.

“Mom, no…Katie took” Maddy pleaded, but my mom cut her off.

“NO, NO! WE ARE DONE WITH THIS. LET HIM SEE IT AND BE DONE WITH IT!”

“Whattt? Let..!” Maddy whimpered. Our mom was close to her now and there was nowhere to run.

“FEAST YOUR EYES, DREW!” Our mom grabbed my sister’s arms and quickly and efficiently moved them off her body and over her head in a full nelson pose.

Finally, I was treated to a full view of Maddy’s tits and….bush!

“Oh Suzanne!” My aunt exclaimed toward our mom.

“Please mom, let me go! Please!” Maddy tried to squirm free but it was futile. She looked over at me. Now she was embarrassed. I kept my eyes on her bulging, bright blue ones as long as I could manage.

Sorry I tried my best to say with my expression. She knew what I was about to do next.

If you must

My eyes bulged out of my skull as they scanned her body. Her boobs were decent sized, firm, and perfectly perky - as I already had figured. Her nipples were soft and puffy and I could barely see the difference between areola and skin. I was surprised at the cute, fluffy, tuft of hair covering her kitty. It was a similar color as the dark autumn leaves outside. She had nice sharp tan lines surrounding her tits and box.

Seeing her stand there, wiggling around in head-to-toe humiliation was too much for me. My dick hurt at this point, and felt like it was going to burst out of my shorts.

“Oh Andrew come on! She’s your little sister!” My aunt scolded me, and pulled me out of my hypnosis.

I finally fidgeted with my penis and began to get the fuck out there.

“Well who can blame him with Maddy constantly parading herself around like this,” I heard my mom say as she struggled to hold Maddy a little longer.

I made my way up the stairs to see Katie observing from the top. She hadn’t been noticed by anyone in the chaos. She granted me an apologetic look. While she clearly meant to embarrass Maddy, she definitely didn’t intent for this to happen. I shook my head at her, not saying anything and locked myself in my room.

[Mick Gesitt]

You go Suzy! I'm still rooting for the mom who's clearly had enough of her kids' shit at this point.

And thanks to my favorite character's involvement, things have rounded a very interesting corner.

Drew has now seen both of the sisters naked.

As much as Katie gives him shit, I'm willing to wager that she enjoys her late night strolls as much as he does. She hasn't busted his chops about jerking off in a while but at this point I figure they're both fully aware of what's happening and that Katie's very clearly putting on a show so I find it highly likely that she frigs herself silly when she gets back to her room.

And then there was Maddy's grand unveiling. Suzanne was very clearly out to drop a Mom Bomb on the situation and get things over and done with. Maddy's go-to move of 'shy' teasing won't hold up much now that Drew's seen everything. So if the story is going to continue and escalate properly... Maddy will have to change up her game a bit.

Let's see...
Maddy left the bathroom in a towel with the very clear intention of showing off.
Katie ripped off Maddy's towel after she stole her 'move'.
But Suzanne was the one who held Maddy in place and forcibly exposed her.
Drew did some very obvious ogling and showed just how much he enjoyed it.
Honestly, the only one who was completely innocent in that whole ordeal was Aunt Nancy.

Perhaps its no more Miss Nice Girl? I wonder if Maddy will be out for some revenge? Maddy was the one who showed an interest in seeing Drew naked so maybe once she gets a proper eye full to even the score she can rope him into helping her get some payback.

[enfanon]

wow! my favorite chapter so far. Keep up the good work!

[Anonymoose]

Drew, I couldn’t possibly be any more enthusiastic with the way this story is progressing so far. I love it when these kinds of stories (particularly with the incest angle) are fun and teasing and embarrassing like this, where it ALMOST feels like something that could actually happen. But most of the time when you look around in this genre it inevitably (and quickly) devolves into lazy HOT HARDCORE BRO-SIS GANG-BANG nonsense that bores the hell out of me. So I’d be thrilled to read you continue on in this vein with these characters (or similar type stories with different characters), but honestly even if you ended it here I’m already more than satisfied.

PS Do not mean to imply that I think you’d be ruining the story if eventually some of the characters got more intimate/physical later on, as I believe you have a good enough handle on things to make it entertaining, just saying that I’m enjoying it more the way you’ve written it so far. Anyway, thanks!