Fly-Fishing: A Game of Chicken - Part 2

[superevil7]

Check out part one here if you haven't already!

_______________________

Part 2

“Oh, boys!” I could hear Patty's voice calling from the banister of the stairs. We both got up to investigate what she was calling us about. From the teasing tone of her voice, I was reminded that I had still agreed to get naked for her any time she liked, and I half expected her to demand that I strip as soon as I reached her. She took my breath away when I saw her. She had a short, transparent pink nightie on, that was only opaque in the bra cups. I could see her little red panties through the material too! I was surprised that she would let us see her like this, but that wasn't the only surprise I would get tonight!

I could hear the whiny voice of my cousins coming from further upstairs behind her. “No, mom! I don't want to do this! Please!” That was Clara, and I could tell she was really upset about whatever was going on.

“No, auntie Jocelyne! Let us go! Please, let us go!” The twins seemed to be pleading for mercy too.

Patty seemed to have an extra pleased look on her face, like this was all her doing. “I hope you enjoy the extra surprise I got for you, Michael.” Just as she said it, my mom and aunt rounded the corner, pulling our cousins along by leashes clipped to collars around their necks! But the thing that really stood out about them was what they were wearing! Clara had been given a crop top, with long sleeves, but the material of the shirt was only long enough to cover up the very upper area of her chest! Her breasts were totally bare and out in the open! Her little pink nipples led the way, as they pointed up and away from her body, and I enjoyed the little jiggle her boobs made with every step she took! She also had a pair of stockings, dark in tone but very see through, that came up to mid-thigh on her. To hold them up, she wore a garter belt that covered none of her pubic mound! I was able to see the lips of a girl's pussy for the first time that day, and I'll never forget the sight! My cousin had no hair down there at all, something she must remove, as I couldn't imagine she wasn't able to grow any hair at her age.

Like their older sister, the twins had their private parts out too! Each of them did have a bit of soft, downy looking hair about their slits, but otherwise their skin looked totally soft and smooth! They were both wearing their knee-high soccer socks, and a button up jersey, but with the buttons missing, to kept their little boobies exposed. Boobies much smaller than their older sister’s, of course. I had never dreamt of getting to see my cousins like this, but I was never so grateful in my life.

“I guess from the smiles on your faces, you boys are pleased with the surprise.” Patty said, making a little wink at me. I blushed a little, but nodded.

“Here's how the game is going to work.” My mom seemed pleased too. She and Aunt Caroline looked to be wearing matching flannel pajamas, which kept them totally covered up in contrast to the girls. “It's the girls turn to play chicken with the boys. You're allowed to do everything to the girls that they did to you, boys, but Patty will be playing the judge, and ruling what is or isn't legal. Now, if the girls don't chicken out, then you will get to play with them this way next year, and the next, and the next, and so on.”

“But if they do chicken out,” My aunt took over, “Then they'll be going naked for every visit the boys make to our house, until they're old enough to vote. We’ll leave it up to you boys if you want to keep them collared, though.”

“How could you do this to us, Patty!!?” Clara complained, and for the first time I noticed that she had her hands bound behind her back! The twins were also equally tied up, and seemed to be squirming as my brother looked them over.

“Wait, this was your idea, Patty?” I asked with surprise.

Patty nodded at me with a grin. “I knew your cousin needed to be brought down several pegs when she told me about what she had planned for you during this visit, Micheal. So, I got in contact with your mom, and your aunt, behind her back, and we came up with a plan of our own.” She turned and patted Clara on the head and stroked her cheek. “You need to be put in your place, Clara, baby. You have nobody to blame for this but yourself. After all, it was your idea to get me involved in the first place. I think after all the tormenting you've done to your cousins, you and your sisters are about to get everything you deserve!” She took the three girl's leashes into her hands, and started leading them down to stand in front of us. “Well, boys,” She eyed the erection in my pants, and then my brother’s too. “Let the game begin!”

I know I felt like I must be dreaming. I took a glance up at my mom, who was still standing at the banister, halfway upstairs, and asked, “We can really do anything to the girls that they did to us?” My mom answered with a nod, so I took a step forward and reached my hands towards Clara's breasts tentatively.

“No! Michael! Don't you dare!” Clara squealed, squirming all around as I got closer. It was making her boobs jiggle quite delightfully! I had never seen a girl's bare breasts up close like this, but I was learning so much about them in a short amount of time. She was trying to back away from me, but Patty was keeping her close with the leash. She wasn't going anywhere unless Patty wanted her to.

I finally made contact with her supple breast skin, and Clara let out an annoyed whine. She started bouncing up and down and shaking in frustration. I used her movement to my advantage, and left my thumbs in place so that her hard pink nipples would glide over them with every bounce she made. “No! Michael! Michael!” She sounded like she was letting out a sob, but I didn't see any tears. She must have been really embarrassed for me to be touching her, was the conclusion I came to.

I wanted her to feel as embarrassed as I had felt, so I started to grope and squeeze her teenage breasts. “Don't tell me this is the first time you've ever had your breasts felt up by a boy. A girl like you, Clara?” I teased her.

“What kind of girl do you think I am!” Clara moaned at me, with a frustrated glare. “I've never let a boy touch me the way you are now!”

“That's a relief to hear.” My aunt commented to my mom, and then they both laughed.

“So, I'm the first boy to ever touch your boobs. You'll always know that it was your cousin Michael that first played with your boobs.” I teased her, and I could see that her face was turning totally red! She let out another whine, but said no more. She just watched as my hands continued to massage her boobs.

“Hey, Micheal.” Patty spoke up after a couple of minutes, “Look at the reaction your cousin is having to what you're doing.” She poked and pushed on one of Clara's legs, but when that didn't work, she resorted to slapping her thighs! She was trying to get my cousin to spread her legs open, and the slaps were enough to get her to do so. “See, she's getting wet being naked in front of you, and from having her breasts stroked.” She explained.

“I am not!” Clara complained, but she turned her head so that she wouldn't have to see me looking at her most private place.

I wasn't going to pass up this opportunity, so I squatted down to get a closer look at what my cousin had between her legs. I reached out a finger, and let it run up and down her slit a few times. Her outer lips were like a flesh clamshell, so I couldn't see anything inside yet, but I did find that my fingertip was covered in moisture when I pulled it away. Her body jerked, as I used the fingertips from both my hands and placed them on her outer clamshell. Then she made another moan as I slowly started to spread her open. “No, Micheal! Please! No! Those are my most private parts! Mom, please! I didn't look inside of Micheal!”

“What do you think, Patty?” Her mom asked, so I paused, waiting for my crush's judgment.

“I think Clara got to see all of Michael's private parts, so Micheal can see all of hers.”

“No!” Clara squealed, but I had a renewed sense that I was getting justice, so I ignored her and resumed pulling apart her little clam lips! Soon I was gazing upon all of her hidden treasures beneath.

“See, that's the opening to her vagina, and that one is her urethra. Oh, and this one you'll find very interesting. It's Gwendolyn’s clitoris. Why don't you try rubbing it?” I looked over and saw that my brother was in a similar position as me, squatting down to get a look at one of the twins’ pussies up close. Patty was explaining all the different parts of a girl down there. I watched as Garrett started rubbing her little nub, and Gwendolyn seemed to go crazy!

“That looks like fun, don't you think?” I asked, looking back over at my blushing cousin Clara, who had been watching too. She gave me a wide-eyed, open-mouthed look, and shook her head at me. “Oh, come on, Clara. It's like you can't get over your modesty, but don't worry. I'm going to break you of it.” I swiped my thumb over her little nub, finding it interesting how it felt like a hard little pebble was embedded under her skin. Clara let out a surprised moan, tensing up at the sudden contact with her most sensitive spot. It was funny watching her reactions, so I did it again, and then a few more times, laughing at the humiliated looks she would give me every time I did it.

“Please, Michael. Not like that! If you're going to do it, just rub it slowly and more consistently.” I heard her voice saying softly.

“So you want me to do it, now?”

She turned her head away from me, and didn't answer. It seemed that I was breaking the girl already. I did as she had asked me to, rubbing my thumb slowly in a circle over her clitoris, and it gave me the exact reaction I was looking for. Her hips slowly started to rock, copying the circle motion I was making on her clit, and she started making little moans of pleasure. “Oh my God. It… it feels so good!...” She said, looking down at me, almost with surprise. I increased the speed of my thumb movements, and she increased how much she was moving. It was like her whole body was getting into it! She was still swiveling her hips in the circular motion, but she was doing it fast enough that her boobs were jiggled about on every one of her up motions! It was a sight I will never forget for as long as I live! Her voice started getting louder and more high-pitched, too. “Yes, Micheal! Yes! Please! Don't stop! I need this so bad! Yes!” She snapped her eyes shut, and I could tell she was really enjoying herself now. “Yes! Yes! Michael! I'm going to cum! I'm going to cum! Ahhhhhh!!!” She let out one loud, high-pitched squeal, and suddenly lost all her rhythm! Her entire body shook and flailed almost violently! Her eyes rolled into the back of her head, and she almost lost her footing! Just to be safe, I lowered her down to the carpeted floor.

My brother seemed to have Gwendolyn nearing the throes of her own orgasm, so while I gave Clara time to rest, I watched him playing with her a bit. Then I noticed Tiffany standing off to the side, looking interested in what we were doing to her sisters, but she also seemed both a little apprehensive and left out. I decided to call her over. “Yes, Micheal?”

She stood in front of me, while I sat on the floor, Indian style. I motioned for her to come closer, until she was practically straddling my lap. She was still standing, and that meant her pelvis was right about eye level with me. I could tell she was getting bashful, as I looked at her bare privates before me. “You have a cute pussy, Tiffany. The little bit of hair you have growing here makes you look mature.” I won't deny, I was enjoying teasing her the same way she had teased me. It felt like the grin was going to become a permanent part of my face, I was smiling so much!

Tiffany looked down with a blush, but then seemed to look back up at me with a little smile. “Thank you, Michael…” She said, actually spreading her legs a little more and tilting her pelvis towards me! Maybe I had Tiffany all wrong, and she was enjoying this?

I decided to put that to the test, and reached out to pet the soft fur she had sprouted above and around her cute little pussy. She let out a giggle at the contact, but didn't move away from me. “I suppose I'm the first boy to touch you here, too?”

She shook her head at me and blushed. “No…” Then she let out another giggle. “Sorry, it tickles.” She explained.

“You've let other boys see you like this?” Clara seemed to have recovered enough to understand our conversation, and she seemed surprised by what her little sister was telling me.

“Yes…” Tiffany pursed her lips. “Well, not like this, but naked. Hahaha! Michael!” Tiffany made another cute giggle as I tickled her little lips with my fingertips.

“It seems like your little sister is way more experienced than you are, Clara.” I teased her, and I could tell that really seemed to bother her.

“But you've not had sex, right?” Clara asked her. I don't think she was asking because she was concerned for her sister. I think it was purely from pride. Clara seemed to be really bothered that her little sister, her normally bashful little sister no less, had a ton more experience in the sexual department than her!

“No! I don't want to have a baby yet!-- Hahahahah!! Michael! Stop tickling me!” She squealed and wiggled.

“Oh, you don't like being tickled, huh?” I reached around her and grabbed her butt cheeks to pull her closer, and then I went to town tickling her all over her apparently very ticklish pussy!

“Oh God! Please! Please!” She begged, falling to the floor and trying to squirm away from me! I grabbed hold of her leash and wrapped it around my wrist, though. She was going nowhere! I continued my attack on her apparently very sensitive pussy lips, and she continued to squirm and laugh, but she was also getting wet! She was small and light enough that I could maneuver her however I liked. I put one of my legs on top of her, tapping her torso in between my thighs, and then I twisted one of her legs back so that I could trap her foot between my calves further down. This meant that she was unable to close her legs, even if she wanted to, and both my hands were free to tease her however I wanted. With her arms already secured behind her back, she could hardly put up any resistance to me to begin with, but this position left her totally vulnerable! With one hand, I kept tickling the outer edges of her pussy, while I used the other one to tease and play with her hard little pink clit! She wheezed with both laughter and moans, and her whole body shook from the intense sensations she was receiving! “Oh my God! Hahaha!! This feels crazy! Hahaha!! Nobody's ever done this to me before! Hahaha!! Michael, you're amazing!” She shouted at me while laughing. It certainly gave me a huge boost to my ego to hear that from a girl, even if it was my little cousin. “Hahaha!! Please! I came! Hahaha!! I came twice!! It's getting too sensitive!!!” She told me, so I had to stop. I just scooped her up in my arms and held her until she was able to catch her breath. Finally, when she could speak again, she said, “Michael, that was amazing!” She kissed me a few times on my cheek and near the mouth, but not exactly on it. “Thank you.” Her bashful side seemed to be coming back, as she blushed deeply at me.

“You're welcome, Tiff.” I gave her a little kiss on the cheek back, and that really seemed to make her blush deeply.

“Just remember he's my boyfriend now.” Patty came over with her hands on her hips.

“I know.” Tiffany looked down sadly. Did she really have a crush on me? “We're cousins, so it wouldn't work anyway.”

“Hey, cheer up. You could always invite one of the boys you like over so I can show him how you like to be touched.” I told her, tilting her chin so that she was looking at me.

Her face seemed to get really red at that idea. “Really?”

“Yeah. Would you like that?” She looked almost faint, but her head made a little nod at me. I made a note in my head to ask Patty about inviting over a boy that Tiffany liked before we headed home tomorrow.

“Alright, I think it's bedtime.” Aunt Caroline announced. It seemed that she and my mom had not been supervising everything, as I saw them returning to the banister out of the corner of my eye. Both Garrett and Gwendolyn seemed to make a disappointed moan. “Tomorrow you'll have the whole day to play with the girls' bodies, Garrett. You'll see.”

As the girls started heading upstairs, my mom stopped them and asked, “So, do you think you girls would chicken out if we let your hands free?”

The twins both shook their heads at her, but Clara spoke up. “Yes! This is so embarrassing! I can't believe I'm walking around with my private parts exposed to Michael and Garrett!” Her voice seemed squeaky, and she took a look back at me, and her face became totally red again.

“Looks like we have our first chicken, Caroline!” Mom seemed pleased, and even rubbed her hands together! She, aunt Caroline, and even Patty closed in around her quickly. Then they started peeling off the clothes she was wearing! The clothes might not have covered her up at all, but it was more symbolic. I remembered what my aunt had said, and realized that Clara would be going naked every time we visited now! With Clara's hands still trapped behind her back, the women and Patty were able to strip Clara with ease, and, as if they were a trophy, Patty tossed her sheer leggings down to me! Then they turned Clara this way and that, so that Garrett and I could get a good look at her fully naked.

“She does have a cute butt!” I couldn't help commenting when they showed me her backside. “I get to keep these?” I asked, holding up Clara's lost stockings and ginning big at my crush. My new girlfriend, I realized!

She nodded. “Yeah, you can hang them up in your room or something.”

“Well, at least I won't have to be felt up by Michael anymore!” Clara declared. I think she was trying to hide just how embarrassed she was to be fully naked now.

Her mom laughed. “Is that what you think? No, that means the boys won, and they get to keep touching you however they want. For winning, they also get the bonus of getting to bathe you every time they visit. What I didn’t tell you about was the extra special penalty that only applies to you. You are going to have to play another game of chicken next week with a boy you like from school.”

“What!? You can't be serious! But mom, that's not fair! None of that is fair!!” Clara squealed with outrage. I couldn't help laughing at her reaction, and she gave me a dirty look.

“Do you think it was fair for you to invite Micheal's crush, Patty, into his game of chicken?” Her mom wrapped her arm around her shoulder. “Come on. Let's go to your room. I'll get your yearbook, and we can pick out which boy you want to play chicken with.”

“But mom!”

“I told you I'd have your father spanking your bare butt every day for a week when he got home if you complained too hard about this. Is that what you want?” Clara just seemed to shudder, but shook her head, as her mom led her the rest of the way upstairs and to her room. My mom and the twins followed, giggling to themselves at Clara's misery the entire time.

When we were over here, Garrett usually slept in a sleeping bag in the den off the first floor, while I took the hide-a-bed in the living room. While my brother left to use the bathroom and get ready for bed, I went over to start pulling the bed out and setting it up for myself. “I can tell you had a lot of fun today.” I turned around to find Patty watching me.

“My God, I never thought I'd be able to get back at my cousins that well! Clara especially!” I squeaked out with excitement.

“I don't think that's the only time you had fun.” I noticed her phone in her hand, and she held it up to show me the picture of me cumming for her in the backyard earlier!

I blushed deeply at her. “Ummmm…”

“Strip, Michael.” She said, giving me the most beautiful grin.

My heart raced, and I wasn't sure if I could do it, but then I remembered the agreement we had made. So, once again, I found myself removing my clothes in front of my crush! Girlfriend! It was so new, and it was going to take some adjusting for me to get used to the idea of that! I fidgeted a little as I stood naked before her. My cock felt like it was as hard as a rock!

“I don't think I'll ever tire of seeing you like this, Michael. It's going to be so much fun knowing that I can make you get naked any time that I want to!” She stepped closer and grabbed a hold of my hard appendage with her soft hand again! She seemed very pleased at the way I was squirming around in her tight grip! “You must feel so powerless when I have you like this. When I hold you like this.”

I looked at her sexy body through the sheer nightgown she was wearing. Even if she was barely covered, all of her essentials were still covered, and I couldn't help hoping that that would soon change. “Are you going to let me see you?” I gulped a little.

She smirked at my question. “Not today, and not for a very long time, Michael. This is about as undressed as you're going to be seeing me.”

“But why did you let me see my cousins then?”

“Because I want you to get a lot of practice before I let you touch me that way.”

“So, I'm not going to get to see you naked?” I asked, a little disappointed.

“Not today. Eventually…” She smirked even bigger at me. “But don't worry, when we get home, all my friends are going to get to see you naked.” She started pumping her fist up and down my shaft as fast as she could! “Rita, Brittany, Angela, Cassidy, they're all going to see you naked! Lou Anne, Margaret, Stephanie, and Grace! They're all going to see you naked too!” I couldn't take it anymore, imagining myself naked in front of all of Patty's girlfriends! I knew that's what she wanted, to make me focus my excitement on her friends all seeing me naked, but it was working! I found myself unable to resist wanting it! I started cumming for the umpteenth time that day, and I was practically dry shooting at this point! “Good boy! I knew you'd like the idea of being naked in front of my friends! Just wait until we actually do it.”

She smiled as I sat down on the edge of the bed to rest. “You better put on your pajamas tonight. I think it'd ruin Clara's punishment if she found you this way in the morning. But don't worry, I think your mom likes having you naked, so it'll be no trouble for me to convince her to let you go naked at home. Oh, Michael, we're going to have so much fun together!” She turned to leave, but I caught her hand before she could. “Michael?”

I stood up and kissed her right on the spot! She seemed to melt into me, and I was tempted to remove her nightie, but then I realized that I really did like our dynamic as it currently stood, and I stopped myself. “Patty? You promise me you'll get me naked in front of all your girlfriends?”

“Cross my heart.” She grinned, drawing my attention to her bra encased bosom. She was hardly dressed, but I felt so much more naked in front of her knowing that her private parts were well hidden from me, and would be for a very long time, apparently. As if she knew what I was thinking, she gave my cock a little tug, just to show me how naked I still was, before wishing me goodnight. I watched her, enjoying the sway of her hips as she climbed the stairs, watching her little red panties from behind that just managed to keep her covered, until she was totally upstairs and disappeared. Only when I was sure she was gone for the night did I slip on my pajama bottoms and crawl into bed. Part of me didn't want her seeing me wearing anything. As embarrassing as it had been for my crush to see me naked today for the first time, I was ultimately happy that my cousin Clara had invited Patty here to visit. I'd have to thank her before we left… But certainly not before I got some more sweet revenge on her!

The End

[NudeBaG]

Great story!
So hot

[superevil7]

Great story!
So hot

I'm so glad you've enjoyed it!

[barelin]

Thanks for posting the link for the first chapter. Over the past month with the spam virus that been attacking this forum it has became hard to read.

[baldeaglet666]

She was small and light enough that I could maneuver her however I liked. I put one of my legs on top of her, tapping her torso in between my thighs, and then I twisted one of her legs back so that I could trap her foot between my calves further down. This meant that she was unable to close her legs, even if she wanted to, and both my hands were free to tease her however I wanted.

Extremely erotic scene. And kudos for describing it succinctly yet still clearly enough that I could imagine the hold. I've taken cracks at writing wrestling/fight scenes before and found myself being bogged down trying to ensure that I was painting a clear enough picture with my exposition. There ended up being way too much text about the execution of the hold that the pacing of the scenes suffered too much. I got fed up and quit. I know this wasn't a fight, but I still appreciate the hold when you just as easily could've had the girl be held by others or something else more dull. Well done!

(Unrelated side tangent that nobody asked for: I would like to shamelessly appeal for more ENF writers to consider wrestling or fights as a story element, whether it's pro-style or schoolyard fights. It's a setting that easily justifies an audience/bystanders for enhanced embarrassment, and once you're in a fight--whether you wanted to be or not--you put yourself totally at the mercy of a presumably hostile opponent that *may just* be sadistic enough to want to deliberately strip you and put you in exposing holds/pins. Combat is one of my favorite fetishes, but so much catfight/wrestling media is overly focused on the pain and/or has characters that are far too brazen for embarrassment and vulnerability to play a factor. Like... If the characters already start the fight willfully naked, I immediately lose interest because I know there won't be an exciting strip progression or much mortification about being maneuvered into an embarrassing hold. Oops, my parenthetical comment is now longer than the main thought. Accursed ADHD.)

[perseus]

A great story! I loved how the game got flipped on the girls from the first part! I'm a sucker for the high a mighty being taken down like that! I especially enjoy the part with Tiffany.

Thank you for writing and sharing

[superevil7]

Extremely erotic scene. And kudos for describing it succinctly yet still clearly enough that I could imagine the hold.

Thanks! I've always felt like describing action was my weak point as a writer, so I'm happy to hear that what I was trying to describe came through clearly to you.

I would like to shamelessly appeal for more ENF writers to consider wrestling or fights as a story element, whether it's pro-style or schoolyard fights. It's a setting that easily justifies an audience/bystanders for enhanced embarrassment, and once you're in a fight--whether you wanted to be or not--you put yourself totally at the mercy of a presumably hostile opponent that *may just* be sadistic enough to want to deliberately strip you and put you in exposing holds/pins.

You make a great point with that. I see a lot more holds and pins being done in ENM and not as much being done in ENF. I certainly think there's room for more.

A great story! I loved how the game got flipped on the girls from the first part! I'm a sucker for the high a mighty being taken down like that! I especially enjoy the part with Tiffany.

Thank you for writing and sharing

Thank you! I always find it fun to flip things around on the girls, so Clara and her sisters were doomed from the start

[Somebody]

Oh this is curious, that link looks like it's to an image on this very site, is it perhaps a spoofed a link using HTML to label as something else? I gotta say the moderation here is not doing an adequate job dealing with this.

[Dorky]

󠇀󠇀󠇀