Any ENF stories where the main girl is mute?

[Bucket]

This one is definitely more of a... well, a strange request, but are there any stories out there where the main character is a mute girl?

I know that might be slightly bizarre. Borderline taboo maybe even, but it is what it is.

Thanks.

[edithdick]

No judgment. I've never seen any store in any genre that focuses on a mute, aside from Helen Keller. Out of curiosity, I googled the phrase "What causes muteness?" and here was the response:

Muteness, or the inability to produce verbal output, can have many causes, including:
Physical injury or trauma
This can include injuries to the throat, larynx, or vocal cords, as well as infections and inflammation of the throat.
Neurological disorders
These can include strokes, brain tumors, or degenerative diseases like amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).
Psychological trauma
This can include childhood abuse, bullying, or family problems. Psychological trauma can cause selective mutism, where a person has the ability to speak but feels unable to, often due to social anxiety or shyness.
Developmental conditions
These can include apraxia of speech or developmental apraxia.
Medical side effects
These can include cerebellar mutism, which is caused by surgery to remove a brain tumor from the cerebellum, and aphasia, which makes speech difficult or impossible after a head injury, stroke, or brain tumor.
Conscious decision
A person may choose to remain mute as a way to manipulate people or their environment, or out of a desire for attention.

Was there any particular version that you are interested in? Also, in your mind, is the mute girl the victim or the aggressor?

[Bucket]

No judgment. I've never seen any store in any genre that focuses on a mute, aside from Helen Keller. Out of curiosity, I googled the phrase "What causes muteness?" and here was the response:

Muteness, or the inability to produce verbal output, can have many causes, including:
Physical injury or trauma
This can include injuries to the throat, larynx, or vocal cords, as well as infections and inflammation of the throat.
Neurological disorders
These can include strokes, brain tumors, or degenerative diseases like amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).
Psychological trauma
This can include childhood abuse, bullying, or family problems. Psychological trauma can cause selective mutism, where a person has the ability to speak but feels unable to, often due to social anxiety or shyness.
Developmental conditions
These can include apraxia of speech or developmental apraxia.
Medical side effects
These can include cerebellar mutism, which is caused by surgery to remove a brain tumor from the cerebellum, and aphasia, which makes speech difficult or impossible after a head injury, stroke, or brain tumor.
Conscious decision
A person may choose to remain mute as a way to manipulate people or their environment, or out of a desire for attention.

Was there any particular version that you are interested in? Also, in your mind, is the mute girl the victim or the aggressor?

Interesting.

Appreciate the feedback. There was a story a read not long ago where there girl was mute and I found it to be a very enjoyable read, though there were some somewhat dark(ish) themes. It had nothing to do ENF or any erotic themes whatsoever, however it made me think that it could actually translate perfectly within an ENF story.

In my mind, the girl would be the victim/embarrassed nude female. Never the aggressor.

"Was there any particular version that you are interested in?"

I'm actually a fan of trauma within stories/fiction. I don't know why, but I am. But then, I've been a horror fan for as long as I can remember, so that could explain it lol. Also witnessed some gory shit as a child, so I guess that counts as trauma, so kind of drawn to it I suppose.

Hope that doesn't make me...odd lol.

Edited sidenote: I just realized you're the author of the Extreme Therapy story. I actually read that and enjoyed it quite a bit. Well, I read the first part. I've not yet read "More Therapy" yet.

I do like heavy, dark themes within stories outside of erotic literature, and am very open to dark/physiological themes within erotic literature too, so I was pleased to see your story contain somewhat dark, physiological themes.

I suppose that that would kind of be what I'd be looking for in a hypothetical mute girl ENF, though not necessarily a necessity.

[edithdick]

In the psychological trauma genre, I could certainly imagine a story where a girl has experienced something so traumatic that she closes herself off verbally as a self-defense mechanism. The antagonist; be it a sibling, a parent, a psychologist, or some other nobly intentioned authority figure attempts to break down this emotional wall by subjecting her to various humiliations with the condition that the treatment will stop when she asks for it to stop.

In that premise, you can go down a number of dark paths.

[Bucket]

In the psychological trauma genre, I could certainly imagine a story where a girl has experienced something so traumatic that she closes herself off verbally as a self-defense mechanism. The antagonist; be it a sibling, a parent, a psychologist, or some other nobly intentioned authority figure attempts to break down this emotional wall by subjecting her to various humiliations with the condition that the treatment will stop when she asks for it to stop.

In that premise, you can go down a number of dark paths.

Ok, I actually really love that idea, I have to say!

Perhaps she was abused as a child, though various other forms of trauma should do, and mutism is the direct result and has been for years. The treatment could involve her brother or even sister (perhaps multiple siblings) assisting her is said treatment, but there'd be a certain... meanness to the story, and have that dark element that has been discussed. Not "meanness" per say, just a story with a relatively dark tone, though it doesn't necessarily have to be dark to work.

A "bad guy" could potentially even be involved, without The protagonist able to say anything about it. The treatment gets more and more intense/humiliating, yet the girl still is unable to verbalize a plea to stop. The more I think about it, the more I'm loving the idea.

Feel like writing said gem? I'd be absolutely, unequivocally on board from start to finish. Just saying.

Feel free to use any of this, and if you ever write anything remotely resembling this, tag me here and I'll be there!

[edithdick]

Feel like writing said gem? I'd be absolutely, unequivocally on board from start to finish. Just saying.

Feel free to use any of this, and if you ever write anything remotely resembling this, tag me here and I'll be there!

I wish I had time to write each day, like I had a couple of years ago. Lately has been so hectic at work and home that I rarely have time to write anything at all. Currently, I am winding down More Therapy. Catwalk is winding up into a Naked in School story and my change of pace story, The Punishment on the ENM board is also setting up for a long slow burn...

THIS story, if I were to write it, would feel more like a mystery, where the audience doesn't get told much about the main character, What caused her trauma? Noone knows. "How long has she been like this?" Uncertain... She might even have been found naked on the side of the road by the police and has not spoken a word. Nobody knows who she is, and so the "caregivers" are doing their best to try an fix her.

Developing a 3 dimensional character who has no known backstory and does not speak sounds like an amazing challenge. I'll start a folder and scrapbook this a bit as I have time. If some compelling story comes from this premise, I will try to write it out.

Otherwise, if you want to take a stab at it, I can certainly be a good sounding board.

[Bucket]

Feel like writing said gem? I'd be absolutely, unequivocally on board from start to finish. Just saying.

Feel free to use any of this, and if you ever write anything remotely resembling this, tag me here and I'll be there!

I wish I had time to write each day, like I had a couple of years ago. Lately has been so hectic at work and home that I rarely have time to write anything at all. Currently, I am winding down More Therapy. Catwalk is winding up into a Naked in School story and my change of pace story, The Punishment on the ENM board is also setting up for a long slow burn...

THIS story, if I were to write it, would feel more like a mystery, where the audience doesn't get told much about the main character, What caused her trauma? Noone knows. "How long has she been like this?" Uncertain... She might even have been found naked on the side of the road by the police and has not spoken a word. Nobody knows who she is, and so the "caregivers" are doing their best to try an fix her.

Developing a 3 dimensional character who has no known backstory and does not speak sounds like an amazing challenge. I'll start a folder and scrapbook this a bit as I have time. If some compelling story comes from this premise, I will try to write it out.

Otherwise, if you want to take a stab at it, I can certainly be a good sounding board.

No worries.

If you get around to it, as I say, I'll 100% be there for it. I'm certainly loving the concept more and more, that's for sure.

"She might even have been found naked on the side of the road by the police and has not spoken a word"

This is actually really brilliant in truth! It kind of implies something severely traumatic happened to her without being too intense for some readers that might have experienced a trauma of a similar nature. I believe the mutism should definitely be a very focal point of the story of course.

Anyway, if ever you decide you're up for the challenge, like I say, tag me here and I'll absolutely be there for it! ☺

[edithdick]

Anyway, if ever you decide you're up for the challenge, like I say, tag me here and I'll absolutely be there for it! ☺

I found that working on multiple stories at the same time is helpful to finding inspiration. That maxes out at 3 stories, any more than that and I get overwhelmed. I have a few unfinished stories that I have completely abandoned in the process of learning that lesson. After the chapter I posted today, I am about 3-4 chapters away from concluding More Therapy. When that is done, I will plan on taking a stab at this story.

No promises, but if I can piece something together for a good old-fashioned mystery/thriller genre story on this topic, I will tag you when it is posted.

[Bucket]

Anyway, if ever you decide you're up for the challenge, like I say, tag me here and I'll absolutely be there for it! ☺

I found that working on multiple stories at the same time is helpful to finding inspiration. That maxes out at 3 stories, any more than that and I get overwhelmed. I have a few unfinished stories that I have completely abandoned in the process of learning that lesson. After the chapter I posted today, I am about 3-4 chapters away from concluding More Therapy. When that is done, I will plan on taking a stab at this story.

No promises, but if I can piece something together for a good old-fashioned mystery/thriller genre story on this topic, I will tag you when it is posted.

Sounds good.

The entire concept definitely is extremely exciting and damn interesting. Has the potential to be tremendous fun. Although I must say, I don't want you to feel obligated to write this btw. If you don't have the time or ha e too much going on, that's totally fine.

If you genuinely like the story/concept and want to write it and xan find the time for it however, then brilliant! I'm extraordinarily intrigued by this potential story and am even brain storming things like the girls name and what she looks like whilst daydreaming lol. (I'm a huge fan of short, petite, preferably submissive female characters for what it's worth)

Anyhow, either way, if you decide to write it, I very much look foward to it!

[randomlygenerated]

Mute girls is also a kink for me, but I have never found a story themed around it. Just found mute girls in media sexy sometimes. I would also be interested if you find anything.